When it was released this remake of Stanley Donen's Charade was considered a complete disaster. In many ways it depressingly ended director Jonathan Demme's ability to combine off beat film making with commercial viability. Demme had been having some decent critical and commercial success in his career. Silence of the Lambs and Philadelphia had performed very well for him.
However he stumbled badly with the Oprah Winfrey project Beloved which was a big commercial disaster. Probably looking for a box office hit he decided to remake Stanley Donen's Charade as The Truth About Charlie. Demme's approach was to film in Paris as a tribute to the French New Wave movement that had started in the 1950's. He got financial backing from Universal Studios and was off and running. "Big Mistake" as Arnold says in The Last Action Hero.
About the only thing Demme got right was casting Thandie Newton in the role that Audrey Hepburn had created in the original film. However things started to go off the rails with his Cary Grant replacement Mark Wahlberg. In short Wahlberg was to put it very mildly no Cary Grant. He looks completely ridiculous running around wearing a beret. Someone should have told him that only tourists wear berets. More importantly he had absolutely no chemistry with Thandi Newton which for a romantic thriller is kind of a problem.
Demme's idea to film this as a tribute to the New Wave was to shoot the film with hand held cameras. The Truth About Charlie is a head ache inducing shaky mess and the camera work a complete distraction to the story. I suppose I could comment on the frenzied editing but what's the point.
Demme also stuck some of the old French New Wave gang into this film. Director Agnes Varda shows up in a couple of scenes and recreates the ending from Truffaut's The Bride Wore Black. Anna Karina, Jean Luc Goddard's one time wife and muse appears. Charles Aznavour the star of Truffaut's Shoot the Piano Player makes a couple of appearances crooning some songs. Finally there is a shot of Francois Truffaut's grave in Montmartre Cemetery. All these New Wave jokes and tributes get really tiresome when the rest of the film is an unwatchable mess.
The Truth About Charlie is the price movie studios and ultimately the audience pays when a quirky filmmaker is allowed to run amuck with his so called personal vision. Demme had only himself to blame. He wrote, produced and directed this film.
The screenplay is by Jonathan Demme, Steve Schmidt, Peter Joshua (the alias for Peter Stone when he knew he was working on a turkey like this), and Jessica Bendinger. The running time is 104 minutes.










































